An audio equipment designer,consultant, and long-time guitarist, 34-year-old R. Aspen Pittman is the president of Groove Tubes [13994 Simshaw, Sylmar, CA91342], which supplies tube sets based on the philosophy that matching their functional characteristics optimizes an amp's performance. He was the sales manager at Los Angeles' Guitar Center for four years, director of marketing and artist relations forAcoustic for seven years, and through his firm, Aspen & Associates, he has served asequipment consultant to Gauss, Cerwin-Vega, Jim Kelley, and groups such as Weather Report and the Doobie Brothers. Pittman's consultant in the preparation of this article was J. Hunt Dabney of JHD Audio[1370 LoganAve., Costa Mesa, CA 92626]. Dabney developed the test methods and provided additionaltechnical support to the company by serving as its head engineer.
By R. Aspen Pittman
Guitarists both today and yesterday are linked in many cases by one piece of equipment: a tubeamp. In fact, the tube amp is currently enjoying its greatest popularity with musician, even though there have been great strides in transistor amp technology over thepast 20 years. Guitarists prefer tube amps.
Why do designs built around tubes sound different from those following the solid-state approach? Simply, tubes work differently. What follows, then, is an explanation of their construction, function, and applications.
Tube Construction And Operation
A tube is an electronic device consisting ofa minimum of four active elements: a heater (filament), a cathode, a grid, and a plate. All of these are sealed in a glass enclosure with its air removed -a vacuum- to prevent the parts from burning. The filament is heated in order to warm thecathode. Once heated, the cathode begins to emit electrons, which flow from the cathode (which is negatively charge) toward the plate (which is positively charged). The grid's purpose is to control this flow. If the grid were absent, this movement of the electrons would be uncontrolled, much like water rushing from the faucet that's opened all the way.
Theory of Operation
When a small signal is applied to the grid, it causes a larger change in the current that flows between the cathode and plate accordingly. In effect, it acts as a valve. A portion of the amp's electronic circuitry, the grid bias control adjusts the proper voltage setting of the grid. The amount of bias varies from tube to tube, depending on its sensitivity, and it acts to keep the tube "idling". When the grid bias is properly set, the tube is balance to the circuit, and therefore produces a clean, powerful signal (proper biasing also extends the life of the tube).
For optimum performance, the bias setting should be checked whenever powertubes are changed-preferably by a qualified technician using an oscilloscope. A bias adjustment is a relatively simple operation, and can be performed for a minimal bench charge (typically $15.00 to $20.00). Some symptoms of improper bias setting include the amp running too hot, excessive hum after it's been on for a short while, or distortion that just doesn't sound right. The amp doesn't necessarily have to sound bad for its tubes to be incorrectly biases, and these symptoms may indicate other problems. However, if your amp is behaving in an extraordinary manner, a trip to the shop may headoff damage to it, regardless of the cause.
Tube Functions In The Amp
Let's look at a common example of how a tubeworks in an amplifier. Imagine a small guitar amp with no volume or tone controls: just a guitar input, one tube, an output transformer, and a speaker. The guitar'spickup produces a small voltage, the result of the string vibrating in the pickup's magnetic field. In general, this signal is applied to the grid, which in turn causes a large current flow from the cathode to the plate. Thus, a correspondingly large voltage now appears at the plate. This plate is connected to an output transformer, which matches the tube's output impedance to that of the speaker. (Because there is agreat disparity between the impedance of the tube amplification circuit and the speaker, the transformer must act as a buffer to interface the two components). Thus, a small, low-power signal from a guitar's pickup can produce a high-powered signal to drive the speakers.
Naturally, amps don't all sound alike. This is due to variations in the type of tube that is used, the quality of the tubes, and the specific circuit design of the amp. In other words, some tubes amplify more than other tubes under similar conditions. Also, the amount of gain a tube produces varies with the circuit design. This is why different makes of tube amps can sound very different, even though they use the same tube types. Additionally, certain amps use completely different types of tubes. A good example of this is the English-type Marshall using European EL-34 tubes in its power amp section, compared to the U.S. type, which employs American-made 6550 power tubes. The U.S. and English styles sound and play very differently, reflecting the character of their power tubes. That is, the English EL-34 tubes yield more distortion than their American counterparts, although they produce roughly the same amountof volume. With internal bias modification (which mostly involves changing some resistance values), any U.S. Marshall amp can use European EL-34s, and vice versa.
Larger and more complex amps have many stages of tube amplification: preamp stages, signal-processing stages, and power amp stages.
The preamp. The preamp stage is much like a mixer in a PA system, which must amplify an incoming mike or guitar signal to line-level strength before the signal can be processed with effects for tonal shaping. Likewise, a tube amp must preamplify a guitar'ssignal so that it can be further processed. This is the first gain stage of the tube amp.
Signal-processing stages. An example of a signal-processing stage is the reverb section, where the signal is diverted through a reverb spring system and then returned by another gain stage, and finally blended with the original signal. Tone controls and second gain stages (often employed for an overdrive effect) are other examples of signal-processing stages.
Power amp stages. The power amp section takes the preamp's signal and amplifies it many times to a level that can drive the speakers. All tube amps with power rating of 10 watts or more employ a push/pull power amp. This means that the power tubes work as a team to amplify the signal and drive the speaker. (Practically all transistor amps employa push/pull configuration as well.) The output tubes all share in the sound, so for maximum efficiency it is desirable to use tubes that operate as similar as possible. Also, for efficiency use power tubes of the same make-manufacturers' specifications for tubes bearing the same stock number may vary over a broad range. And, if one power tube is bad, it is advisable to change all of them. Having one fresh, powerful tube and three old ones, for example, can create an imbalance in the push/pulleffect, resulting in inefficient operation. The power amp section is only as strong as its weakest link. So, if one tube out of four is faulty or varies from the others in its performance character, the overall sound of the amp will be limited.
The process of output tube matching dates back almost as far as tube amps. The military began matching certain properties of tubes to produce longer field life and higher performance. Later, top audio companies such as McIntosh developed asystem to match power tubes for use in their audio amps, and would guarantee performance specifications only when their matched tube sets were used. Unfortunately, it isimpossible to specifically manufacture matched power tubes because of the mechanical nature of the device and the extreme operating temperatures that exist within the tube (around 700 F). However, once the tube is made, it can be performance tested for various parameters and matched into sets with identical characteristics.
Since a tube is a mechanical assembly of parts that forms an electronic device, it is subject to some mechanical problems and limitations. Tubes wear out in direct proportion to how hard they are worked (due tothe circuit design) and how often and loud you play your amp. Vibration and jarring shorten the useful life of the tube as well. Ideally, a tube could be built so that no vibration existed between its mechanical elements. However, adverse tube microphonics can be a big problem when the elements of the tube rattle or ring, producing a signal all by itself. A tube with this problem is unsuitable for use in music amps, much like a faulty guitar pickup or a bad microphone is undesirable for most musical purposes.
When To Replace Tubes
So, when should you change your tubes? Chances are, your power tubes are worn out when your amp starts sounding weak, lacks punch, makes funny noises, has its power fading up and down, or loses highs or lows. If your amp squeals, is excessively noisy, loses gain in one channel, hums, lacks sensitivity to touch, or generally feels as if it's working against you, a preamp tube could be malfunctioning, and is in need of replacement. In both cases, though, the tubes may not be at fault. Unless you are skilled in specific trouble shooting, regard the high-voltage circuits found in amplifiers as extremely dangerous. Take the amp to a professional for diagnosis and repair.
Unfortunately, you can't simply pull your tubes out and take them to the drugstore or local electronics outlet and evaluate them on one the tube-testing machines designed for TVs. This is because of the high voltage levels at which guitar amplifier tubes are driven. Amp tubes can be powered with 450 volts or more, whereas the testing machine provides only about 150 volts. This difference can completely foul up a diagnosis. Tube-for-tube replacement and a before-and-after comparison is often the most reliable test.
Good-sounding, non-microphonic preamp tubes are the exception, not the rule. Quality preamp tubes along with matched sets of power tubes are a little harder find, and you may par more when you do locate them. However, you can expect improved sound and longer life, so there is a payoff.
Tubes, Transistors, and Distortion
No tube primer would be complete without an explanation of how tubes distort in a way that is different from transistors. Tubes distort uniquely because as the signal emitting from the plate approaches its maximum potential, the tube gradually begins to react less and less to the original input signal. This results in a types of compression of the signal, and produces a soft clipping. Clipping occurs when the input signal increases but the maximum power has been reached. Thus the signal becomes cut off, or clipped. Transistors, on the other hand, react exactly the same to the input signals rights up to their maximum power; then they stop quickly, creating a sharp clipping. These different types of clipping produce different series of harmonics (overtones). When the transistor amp clips, it produces more odd-order harmonics (and in its worst case can sound hollow and dry), whereas tube distortion produces even-order harmonics. Tube distortion sounds warmer. It should be mentioned that various types of transistor and tube distortion are possible, depending the amp's design.
In the case of a tube amp, preamp and power amp tubes have different distortion characteristics due to the difference in both their tubes and their circuit design. For example, relying on a master volume distortion circuit by itself will yield less sensitivity to variations in a player's touch than if the amp is attenuated (has its volume limited) after its power stage (that is, with a power attenuator). This is due to the contribution of the output transformer to the soundof the amp and also to the difference in sonic qualities between different power tubes compared to preamp tubes. Leaving some of the distortion to the power amp section rather than relying mainly on the preamp section gives a broader range of sensitivity. In addition, the nature of the tube allows the player to vary his touch, producing different tonal responses from the amp according to the manner in which he plays.
There are many variables in tube amp design, and each has its characteristic sounds and quirks. Regardless of what type of amp you use, you will find that like strings on guitars or oil in an automobile, tube do wear out. Amps are not maintenance-free, and as they age, they undergo changes. The tubes are subjected to wear and tear, some of the electronic parts lose their initial properties, and pots and jacks get old. Bad tubes can cause premature failure of other parts, such as the output transformer, speaker, and other vital components. If your amp sound bad, weak, or otherwise not up to par, don't just hope the problem will go away. Get it fixed. Keep on top of the maintenance, replace the tube when necessary, and get the most form your amp.